
More than a million families have received foreclosure notices
The American dream has been since World War II for a family to own its own home. Housing ownership was also thought of as a forced savings plan. This is because for 70 years, every year without interruption, the housing market experienced a gain in prices. During 70 years, not a single year of residential housing prices decreasing. Yes there were sections of the country that declined, but never the entire county itself. There were a whole set of reasons for this. They included:
- Our population was growing
- Our wealth was growing – GNP was increasing regularly with very few recessions interrupting the growth
- The tax code was biased towards housing ownership due to the deductibility of both mortgage interest and real estate taxes
- People just saw a never ending stream of price appreciation and thought it would never end.Â
Now for the vast majority of those 70 years there were no fun and games. By this I mean, you bought the house, and when you sold it, you took out the profit. In the meantime, while you owned the house the price appreciation sat there. It was never available to you unless you sold the house.
 The fun and games started in the early 1990’s when home equity loans came into existence. People started to borrow money based on the built in appreciation during the holding period. For the first time, owners could take out cash without selling the property. Starting in 2000, the borrowing went big time. People borrowed so much based on their home value that the American consumer began for several years to spend 109% of his income year after year.Â
This means you spent all of your income with no savings and then spent another 9% on top of that income, based on your home equity loans and credit card build-up. It was a party and everything wanted to come. Housing prices exploded and people started to buy additional houses on speculation, and their credit rating, and then the banks relaxed their credit standards on new mortgage approvals. Millions of people bought properties that they really could not afford. The banks believed as they always believed that the appreciation in housing values would bail them out, even if the house owner could not pay the mortgage payment.Â
The House Came Tumbling Down
As you know the banks and investment firms beginning in the 21st century began to bundle mortgages in $100 million dollar increments and then sold off the mortgages as triple A rated paper (it never was triple A) to institutions and individuals who got suckered. The paper collapsed as it eventually had to, and this resulted in the banking crisis of 2008 and 2009 which required the American Tax Payer to bail out the banks with an $800 billion cash infusion, or in the absence of a bailout we would risk the whole economy swiftly going over the edge instantly into a 1930’s style Great Depression.Â
As an aside, I believe Nancy Pelosi, the House Speaker literally saved America by acting swiftly, even though I deeply resent having to bail out stupid bankers acting more stupidly based on greed, and the concept that everybody is doing it. I am also surprised that the rating agencies have not been dismantled as a result of their stupidity.Â
Where We Are At TODAY?
At the moment, the federal government is stuck with 250,000 homes in its possession. That works out to roughly one third of the 800,000 houses that have been repossessed during this period. There are also hundreds of thousands of additional homes that will be foreclosed on. For housing prices to move up from here, these homes have to come off the market. They have to be owner occupied.
You cannot have a bifurcated market which means two –tier pricing. Nobody is going to buy a $300,000 house next door to a foreclosed house that may go for $225,000. These foreclosed homes are an overhang on the real estate market and they will continue to be. I think it takes years to work out, for these houses to come off the market.
Currently, three agencies, Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, and the Federal Housing Administration have been putting their brains together (an oxymoron) to see if they can come up with a way to get rid of this inventory of foreclosed homes. So far, they have failed nothing new there.
The CONCLUSIONS are Simple
- There will be no nation wide growth in housing prices so long as there are one million homes that have been foreclosed upon, and more on the way.
Â
- The economy in my opinion cannot have sustained growth in the 3% area unless these houses are again occupied by new owners. The housing market is such a major factor in our economy that the nation’s growth depends upon it. When you buy a house, you furnish it, you fill the closets, and you fill the garage, maybe an additional car. Hey, it’s like a boat which is a hole in the ocean that you just keep pouring money into.
- We can in the absence of moving this housing inventory have an economy that muddles along at 0 to 1% growth rates, and continued high unemployment, but 3% growth which is what we need just to absorb new college graduates, it’s simply not in the cards.
Â
- As for my investment thoughts, I believe that it has never been a stock market; it is instead a market of stocks. You pick the right ones and you will be on easy street. I still like certain banks and I am expecting 100% gains over a couple of years, and don’t forget there’s dividend capability with the banks as well.  Â
Richard Stoyeck
4 Comments »